Call frequency by decile: a cadence the map can keep
How to turn prescriber deciles into weekly, twice monthly and monthly calls, check the plan against the days you have, and adjust for who responds.
Adam DeLeon · Founder, Adelo CRM
9 min read
Call frequency by decile is the rule that says how often you see a prescriber based on where they rank: the top deciles weekly, the next ones twice monthly, a few more monthly, everyone else when you are nearby. The rule only works if you set it from the bottom up, starting with how many calls your days can actually hold, and then deciding where each frequency stops. Set it from the top down and you will promise more calls than the month has, and the lowest tier will quietly go unseen.
Below is how to read your deciles, how to turn them into a cadence, a worked territory with every number stated, and what the research says about the gap between who writes the most and who responds the most.
First, know what your deciles are counting
Before you attach a frequency to a decile, answer two questions about the file.
Which end is the top? In the files most reps see, 10 is the highest writer and 1 the lowest, but conventions vary by vendor and by company. Check before you build anything on it.
Are the deciles equal in people or equal in volume? This one matters more than it sounds. Some files split the list so each decile holds the same number of prescribers. Others split it so each decile holds the same share of total prescriptions, which means the top decile is a handful of heavy writers and the bottom decile is a crowd.
Here is why it matters. Say you have 360 prescribers and the rule is "deciles 9 and 10 are weekly."
| How the deciles are cut | Prescribers in deciles 9 and 10 | Weekly calls a month |
|---|---|---|
| Equal numbers of people | 72 | 288 |
| Equal shares of volume (example) | 28 | 112 |
Same rule, same territory, and one version costs more than two and a half times the other. A rep with about 220 calls a month to spend could live with the second. The first would eat the whole month before a single twice monthly call.
So never copy a decile rule from another territory, or from a national plan, without counting what it costs on your own file.
Turn deciles into a cadence, from the bottom up
The method has four steps, and the order matters.
- Count your capacity. Work out how many calls each weekday can hold, given how far apart the offices are in that day's zone. Add them up for a week, then multiply by the field weeks in the month. The arithmetic for one day is in ten to twelve calls a day is a consequence, not a target.
- Decide how much to commit. Promise around 80 percent of that capacity. The rest is for coverage, new writers, callbacks and the days that go sideways.
- Price each decile. For every decile, multiply the number of prescribers by the calls a month each frequency costs: weekly is 4, twice monthly is 2, monthly is 1.
- Draw the lines. Starting at the top, give weekly to deciles until adding the next one would crowd out the tiers below it, then twice monthly, then monthly, until the committed total reaches your 80 percent. Everyone below the last line is coverage.
The key idea is that you are spending a budget. A decile does not earn weekly calls by being high. It earns them if the budget still has room after you have paid for it.
A worked territory
Here is a made up territory with every input stated, so you can redo it with your own.
Capacity. Five weekday zones that hold 12, 11, 10, 12 and 11 calls, which is 56 a week. Four field weeks a month gives 224 calls. Eighty percent of that is about 180 calls to commit.
The file. Deciles cut by volume, so the counts grow as you go down. Deciles 4 and below are left out of the table; they are coverage in every version.
First pass, the common rule. Deciles 10 and 9 weekly, 8 and 7 twice monthly, 6 and 5 monthly.
| Decile | Prescribers | Frequency | Calls a month |
|---|---|---|---|
| 10 | 12 | Weekly | 48 |
| 9 | 16 | Weekly | 64 |
| 8 | 20 | Twice monthly | 40 |
| 7 | 26 | Twice monthly | 52 |
| 6 | 32 | Monthly | 32 |
| 5 | 40 | Monthly | 40 |
| Total | 146 | 276 |
That is 276 calls committed against 224 the month holds, 123 percent, before any coverage. On paper it looks like a sensible plan. In the car it means decile 5 and 6 never get their monthly visit, and by spring someone asks why the rep keeps falling behind.
Second pass, lines drawn from the budget. Move each line up one step. Decile 10 weekly, 9 and 8 twice monthly, 7 and 6 monthly, 5 becomes coverage.
| Decile | Prescribers | Frequency | Calls a month |
|---|---|---|---|
| 10 | 12 | Weekly | 48 |
| 9 | 16 | Twice monthly | 32 |
| 8 | 20 | Twice monthly | 40 |
| 7 | 26 | Monthly | 26 |
| 6 | 32 | Monthly | 32 |
| Total | 106 | 178 |
Now 178 of 224 calls are committed, about 79 percent. The 46 left over each month are for decile 5 and below when you are in their zone, for new writers, and for the week a road closes.
Notice what moved and what did not. Nobody in a tier had their frequency watered down to make the math work. The lines between deciles moved, which is the honest version of the same decision. There is more on that trade in a call cadence only works if the map agrees with it.
Then check every weekday
A month can balance while one day overflows, because the tiers are not spread evenly across the map. Place each prescriber in the zone where their office is, and count a typical week as all the weekly calls, half the twice monthly ones and a quarter of the monthly ones.
| Day | Holds | Weekly | Twice monthly | Monthly | Typical week |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Monday | 12 | 3 | 8 | 12 | 10 |
| Tuesday | 11 | 2 | 8 | 12 | 9 |
| Wednesday | 10 | 2 | 6 | 10 | 7.5 |
| Thursday | 12 | 3 | 8 | 12 | 10 |
| Friday | 11 | 2 | 6 | 12 | 8 |
| Week | 56 | 12 | 36 | 58 | 44.5 |
Every day has room. If one did not, say Wednesday came out at 11 on a zone that holds 10, the first fix is to move a few ZIP codes from Wednesday into a day with slack, not to drop someone's frequency. Twice monthly also needs to land as weeks one and three, or two and four, so a provider is not seen two weeks running and then not for three.
A decile measures volume, not response
Everything above treats the decile as the right ranking. It is a good ranking of who writes the most. It is not a measure of who will write more because you showed up, and the research on detailing keeps finding that the two are different.
Heavy writers can be over called. A study by Puneet Manchanda, Peter Rossi and Pradeep Chintagunta looked at individual physicians for one drug in a mature category. As Chicago Booth Review reported it, high volume physicians got far more calls than low volume ones, the least responsive physicians got almost twice as many calls as the most responsive, and calls did not line up with responsiveness for about half of the physicians studied.
Returns fall as calls pile up. Anusua Datta and Dhaval Dave tracked physicians and one promoted drug over time and found that detailing raised new prescriptions, but that the effects diminish at higher levels of promotion. Most of the effect came from getting a physician to prescribe the drug at all, rather than from getting an existing writer to write more.
Volume still matters, just not alone. The same paper found the response to detailing was largest among physicians with the highest market volume. So the decile is not wrong. It is incomplete.
New patients may matter more than total volume. Research by Tulikaa Bhatia and Lakshman Krishnamurthi, reported by Kellogg Insight, found detailing had more influence on a first prescription than on later ones, and that shifting calls toward physicians with the highest share of new patients beat targeting the heaviest prescribers in their simulation.
Response changes over time. Sridhar Narayanan and Puneet Manchanda studied detailing for a new drug and found that physicians differ a lot in how fast they learn from it, and that those who respond most early on tend to respond less later. A frequency that made sense at launch may not make sense a year in.
None of this says throw out the deciles. Your company built them from real data and a homemade score usually does worse. It says the decile is where you start and your own knowledge is how you finish. A few adjustments worth making by hand, one name at a time, and writing down so your manager can see them:
- Move up a decile 6 or 7 who just started writing your product, or an office taking on a lot of new patients, such as a practice that just added a provider.
- Consider moving down a decile 10 who already writes your product for nearly every patient it fits and sees a stream of reps every day. Twice monthly may hold that relationship as well as weekly does, and frees four calls a month.
- Check after a quarter. Treat each move as a test. If the writing moved, keep it. If not, put the name back.
Keep these to a handful. A decile plan with forty hand edits is no longer a decile plan, and nobody can tell whether it worked.
When to redo the lines
Redraw the decile lines at the start of a quarter, or when a new data release lands, not in the middle. Offices notice when your day changes, and a promise that moves every few weeks is not a promise. Review the plan monthly against what was worked: calls planned and made by decile, and the names missed twice in a row. If the bottom tier keeps slipping, that is a capacity problem showing up as a performance problem, and the fix is to move a line, not to work harder.
If you would rather not price every decile by hand, Adelo CRM takes the target file you already have, scores and tiers it, carves the territory into weekday zones, places weekly, twice monthly and monthly calls on the calendar, and counts drive time against the clock for every day, so you can see whether the cadence fits before the quarter starts. For the whole plan around it, see how to build a pharmaceutical sales territory plan.
Questions people ask
What call frequency should each decile get?
There is no universal answer, because it depends on how many prescribers sit in each decile and how many calls your days can hold. A common starting shape is weekly for the top decile, twice monthly for the next two and monthly for the two below that. Price it on your own file and move the lines until the total is about 80 percent of your capacity.
What does decile mean in pharmaceutical sales?
It is a ranking of prescribers into ten groups by how much they write, usually for a market or a product. Check which end your company treats as the top, and whether each decile holds the same number of prescribers or the same share of prescriptions, because that changes how many people a rule like "top two deciles weekly" covers.
How many times should a pharma rep see a top decile doctor?
Often weekly or twice monthly, but more is not automatically better. Research on detailing finds the effect of each extra call shrinks as calls pile up, and that the heaviest writers are not always the most responsive. If a top writer already uses your product for nearly every patient it fits, ask whether the fourth call of the month is doing more than a call to a newer writer would.
Should you call on low decile prescribers at all?
Yes, as coverage, when you are already in their zone. Low decile includes prescribers who are new, who just changed practices, or whose patients the data does not see well. Visiting them when the route passes by costs little, and it is how you find the next name to move up a tier.
Sources
- Effects of Physician Directed Pharmaceutical Promotion on Prescription Behaviors: Longitudinal Evidence, Anusua Datta and Dhaval Dave, NBER Working Paper 19592, 2013, on diminishing effects of detailing and larger effects in higher market volume.
- Marketing Prescription Drugs, Chicago Booth Review, 2004, reporting Manchanda, Rossi and Chintagunta on call allocation and physician responsiveness.
- The Devil Is in the Detailing, Kellogg Insight, reporting Bhatia and Krishnamurthi on first prescriptions and new patient share.
- Heterogeneous Learning and the Targeting of Marketing Communication for New Products, Sridhar Narayanan and Puneet Manchanda, Marketing Science, 2009.
Written by Adam DeLeon, Founder, Adelo CRM. Where a figure appears it is either arithmetic you can redo from the inputs in the text or it is labeled as an assumption. None of it is a customer outcome.